How to Turn Sour Reviews into Sweet Writing Success

posted in: Uncategorized | 0


As an amateur chef, my love for cooking is rivaled only by my love for…actually, scratch that. Nothing rivals my love for cooking.

Or eating.

But here’s the thing: once upon a time, my spatula-wielding skills were about as sharp as a butter knife. Yeah, I wasn’t always the Kitchen Ninja that I am today.

Truth be told, my early attempts at playing gourmet chef at home were more like a disaster movie than a cooking show. I’d whip up what I thought were epic dishes, only to be met with faces that looked like they’d just bitten into a lemon—sour and a little shell-shocked.

And let me tell you, it stung. Like accidentally grating your finger instead of the cheese kind of sting. I mean, I loved those dishes. They were my babies, my culinary masterpieces. “Best” was an understatement—I thought they were the food equivalent of the Mona Lisa. In my mind, my family would be high-fiving me over the dinner table, not reaching for the nearest bucket. But hey, we live and learn, right?

You all know where this is going.

Writing is a lot like cooking a complex dish. You start with basic ingredients—your thoughts, ideas, and experiences—and blend them together to create something that will tantalize the world’s palate. Sounds simple enough, right?

But here’s the rub. Just like any ambitious chef, creative people will face feedback and criticism, both the Michelin-star praise and the ‘did they even taste my dish?’ kind of comments. These come from your fellow cooks, food critics, and even those friends who think a microwave meal is gourmet cooking.

And believe me, digesting this feedback, understanding the taste it leaves behind, and learning from it is not just about adding another recipe to your collection—it’s the secret ingredient to growing and improving as a chef of words. So don your apron, brace yourself for the heat of the kitchen, and remember: every critique is just another spice in the complex recipe of your writing journey.

Alright, let’s start with this: criticism is a lot like that friend who always tells you when you have spinach stuck in your teeth. Sure, it’s initially awkward, but you’re thankful for it in the end. When it’s delivered constructively, criticism is like striking gold, but instead of shiny nuggets, you’re unearthing nuggets of wisdom.

It’s like having a pair of fresh eyes, pointing out the things you’ve missed—you know, like those plot holes big enough to swallow a truck, phrases that sound like they’ve been spat out by a malfunctioning translation app, or sections that are as clear as a foggy day in London.

Constructive criticism is the editor in your corner, helping you polish your prose until it gleams brighter than my forehead on a hot summer day. It’s all about refining your work, boosting its readability, flow, and overall impact, so it goes from ‘meh’ to ‘marvelous.’ So remember, the next time you receive criticism, think of it as a helpful friend, not a spinach-stalking nemesis.

Positive criticism, my friends, is the pat on the back, the ‘well-done’ roast of a Sunday dinner, the standing ovation at the end of a performance. It’s more than just an ego massage, though—it’s like a personal GPS, helping writers pinpoint their ‘wow’ factors. Maybe it’s their voice, as unique as a singing parrot on a unicycle. Or their descriptions, so vivid they make a 3D movie look like a child’s sketch. Or their storytelling, so compelling it could make a sloth run a marathon.

Knowing what you’re good at is like finding your secret superpower—it helps you focus, refine, and amplify it. It’s like discovering you’re really good at impressions and deciding to host a one-person show. Plus, let’s be real, who doesn’t like to feel accomplished? Positive feedback is the fuel that keeps our creative engines humming and our fingers flying across the keyboard. So bring on the gold stars, we’ve got stories to tell!

Criticism, when delivered constructively, is a goldmine of learning. It provides an outside perspective, illuminating the blind spots that a writer might overlook. This feedback can pinpoint areas of improvement, such as plot inconsistencies, awkward phrasing, or lack of clarity, which the writer may have missed. Constructive criticism helps writers refine their work, enhancing its readability, coherence, and overall impact.

Positive criticism, or praise, while a morale booster, can also be instructive. It helps writers identify their strengths—be it their unique voice, their vivid descriptions, or their compelling storytelling. By understanding what they excel at, writers can further hone these areas, enhancing their distinctive style and voice. Positive feedback also motivates writers, fostering a sense of accomplishment and encouraging them to keep writing.

Negative criticism, on the other hand, can initially be hard to swallow.

Rest assured, there are those who will read this post, roll their eyes, scoff and leave a scalding one-star review. Though I won’t lose sleep over that lonely luminary, it can sting, especially when the writing piece is something the author has invested a lot of time and emotion into. However, negative feedback is invaluable for growth. It provides a different perspective and challenges the writer to question their assumptions, pushing them to strive for better. It’s important to remember that negative criticism is usually about the work, not the writer. Separating oneself from the work can make it easier to accept and learn from negative feedback.

Here’s the twist: criticism is also like your personal trainer—it’s there to beef up your resilience. Think of it as your emotional gym, where each critique, especially the harsh ones, are like reps that build your emotional biceps. You’re not just writing here, you’re pumping iron with your feelings!

Think of it as an opportunity to grow some emotional calluses. And trust me, in the writing world, you’re going to need skin thicker than a rhino’s—because rejection and criticism here are as common as typos in a rushed text message. But remember, just like a good workout, every critique brings you one step closer to becoming a heavyweight champ in the literary ring.

But here’s a little secret: not all criticism is created equal. Some feedback is as useful as a chocolate teapot. I know. I know. That’s an overused idiom, but it’s true.  There’s the kind of critique that comes from a place of personal bias or misunderstanding, like someone who’s allergic to strawberries criticizing a strawberry pie. It’s not the pie’s fault, buddy!

So, it’s up to you to play the role of a savvy feedback detective. You’ve got to learn to tell the difference between criticism that’s going to help you grow and the kind that should be forgotten as soon as it’s read.

Criticism also teaches resilience. The ability to accept and process criticism, particularly negative, builds emotional strength and perseverance. It’s an opportunity to develop a thicker skin—a trait that’s particularly useful in the writing world, where rejection and criticism are part and parcel of the journey.

But it’s crucial to filter the criticism you get. Not all feedback is constructive or helpful. Some criticism might stem from personal bias or misunderstanding on the part of the critic. Knowing what feedback to take on board and what to disregard is a skill that develops over time, through experience and insight.

Criticism should not be seen as a discouragement but rather as a tool for growth. It’s an opportunity to see your work through someone else’s eyes, providing useful insights for improvement. By accepting and understanding criticism, writers can refine their craft, enhance their resilience, and continue to grow.

In the grand scheme of things, handling criticism—be it a pat on the back or a kick in the pants—is a must-have tool in any writer’s toolbox. It’s like the secret ingredient in Grandma’s famous cookies—it can really amp up your game, leading to supercharged improvement, personal growth, and a smooth final draft. Remember, every piece of constructive criticism is like a breadcrumb on the trail to writing greatness.

Handling negative criticism without getting discouraged can be hard, especially when it involves a piece of work you’ve poured your heart and soul into. Here’s how I handle those love-to-hate-it, wish-they-were-written-in-invisible-ink, dreaded one-star reviews.

  • Splitting Personalities. No, I’m not suggesting you channel your inner Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. Rather, it’s about realizing that a critique of your work is not a critique of you. It’s like if someone didn’t like your couch—it doesn’t mean they don’t like you, just that your taste in furniture isn’t their cup of tea. Remember, it’s your writing in the spotlight, not your entire existence as a writer. So, take a deep breath and don’t take it personally.

  • Think about who’s dishing out the critique. If it’s from a seasoned writing mentor, a pro editor, or a fellow pen-wielding comrade, then it may be worth its weight in gold. But if it’s from some random keyboard warrior hiding behind a screen, it might be better to take it with a pinch of salt.

  • Next up, we’ve got the Abe Lincoln Chill-Out Method. Now, you may not wear a top hat or sport a beard, but you can certainly borrow a page from Honest Abe’s playbook. When faced with criticism or someone who’d ruffled his feathers, he’d write a letter or a note and then put it aside until he cooled off. He knew the value of not reacting in the heat of the moment. So when you get a critique that stings like a bee, don’t rush to react. Instead, hit the pause button, take a few deep breaths, and let those initial emotions simmer down. Once the storm in your teacup has calmed, you’ll be in a better position to evaluate the feedback without the rose- or gray-tinted glasses of immediate emotional reaction.

  • Even in the harshest critic, there’s often a nugget of truth hiding—like finding a piece of popcorn at the bottom of an otherwise empty bucket. Try to dust off any hurt feelings and dig for any valid points that are buried in the critique. Who knows, even if it was served up with all the finesse of a bull in a china shop, there might be a useful tip or two you can pocket.

  • Finally, never forget your ‘Why’: Don’t let a storm of negative criticism blow you off your writing path. Remember why you first put pen to paper—whether it was the thrill of weaving words, the urge to tell a tale, or the need to pour out your heart. That spark of passion is your personal fire, and no amount of huffing and puffing from critics should ever put it out. Keep that flame burning bright and continue to light up the world with your words.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *